A Wizard of Earthsea

A Wizard of Earthsea
by Ursula K. LeGuin
Reviewed by Mrs. Jones

I love the Harry Potter books.  I've often read that the Harry Potter books are very good, but not very original; that they pull elements from lots of other good books.  They borrow from the British tradition of boarding-school books, from mythology, and also from an old kids' fantasy novel called A Wizard of Earthsea, which is also about a boy wizard at wizard school.

Now I've finally read A Wizard of Earthsea, and I don't think it's very much like Harry Potter at all.  Yes, they both have young wizards who go to wizarding school, but that's the end of the similarity.  In LeGuin's novel, the young wizard is Ged, who shows magic talent as a boy, and is sent away to be an apprentice wizard.  In his ignorance, he uses his magic to unleash something very big and very dangerous, and then goes to the great wizard academy to learn to control his power.  He learns, and grows, and begins to come of age, but through everything, the dark power he awoke as a boy is following him.  This book is a lot more serious than Harry, slower paced, and with more emphasis on beautiful language.  Also, Ged doesn't actually spend that much of the book at wizarding school

One thing A Wizard of Earthsea does have in common with the Harry Potter series is that they're both coming-of-age stories, showing how a child grows into a man.  I loved the way that Ged isn't a perfect child.  He makes big mistakes and wrong decisions, and he has to live with the consequences of his decisions, even when he has learned better.

I also loved the emphasis on the power of language in this novel.  The magic system is based on the power of words.  Wizards speak an ancient language in which it is impossible to lie, and knowing the true name of a person or thing gives you a tremendous amount of power - therefore, a great deal of the work of being a wizard involves trying to discover the real name and nature of whatever one wants to control.  The language of the novel was truly extraordinary.  I've often been irritated at the phony lyricism of some fantasy novels.  I can't read too many sentences of "Forsooth, thou must go unto yon castle, for a geas is laid upon thee" before I get annoyed and quit reading.  But LeGuin uses language that is beautiful, lyrical, and old-fashioned, while still being perfectly readable.  I found myself pausing to re-read an especially beautiful sentence or paragraph more than once.

I loved reading A Wizard of Earthsea, and I can't believe I'm only now reading it for the first time, because I would have loved it as a teenager.  It's wise and beautiful and true, and I hope the second book in the series is as good as the first, because I already have it on hold at the library.

Welcome

Welcome to Race Street Station!  Here are the formal guidelines for submitting writing to this blog.                                          
I'm Heather Jones, and I'm a teacher at the School for Creative and Performing Arts, in Cincinnati, Ohio.  The posts on this blog reflect my own opinions, and the opinions of my students, and are not the official opinions of the School for Creative and Performing Arts.  This blog is not an official publication of SCPA.

Guidelines for student writers

Purpose

Race Street Station's purpose is to inform our readers about middle grades books they might enjoy and about what it's like to be a young artist in Cincinnati, while entertaining our readers.

Audience

Our audience is 11-15 year olds who read for pleasure, and their parents and teachers.  

Length

Book reviews should be 250-500 words long.

Essays should be 500-1000 words long.

Topics

We publish positive book reviews, positive opinions, good advice, and personal stories about learning, growing, and making good choices.

We do not publish negative book reviews or negative opinions, bad advice, or personal stories that would be likely to hurt or seriously embarrass a person.

We review books that are specifically written for middle-grades readers, and also books that are written for teen or adult readers, but that middle-grades readers are likely to enjoy.  Please do not submit reviews for teen or adult books that include scenes of explicit sex or violence.    

If we have published a personal story that harms you, or reviewed a book with explicit sexual or violent content, please contact Mrs. Jones.

Publication Privacy for student writers

Students are invited, but not required, to submit their writing to be published on Race Street Station.  Not all submissions will be published; I will select the writing that I think best meets the needs of the blog.  I am looking for posts that are informative and entertaining, that are written with excellent grammar and a strong sense of voice, and that bring something to our readers that isn't already on the blog.

I will edit posts for spelling, grammar, and punctuation, but submissions with more than a few errors will not be accepted for publication.  I am available during private tutoring sessions to help you polish the mechanics of your writing before you submit it; please schedule an appointment with me.

To protect student privacy, student posts will be signed with the author's first name and last initial.  Students who want additional privacy may use a pseudonym.

Diversity statement

Race Street Station welcomes writing about a diverse range of life experiences.  We do not discriminate based on race, color, national origin, sex, disability, religion, sexual orientation, or gender expression.